Contract

the citation graph

HASAN AND CHAUSH v. BULGARIA

2000-10-26 · European Court of Human Rights · Council of Europe

read the judgment

8What it rests on

19Relied on since

0Departed from

Relied on since

The judgments that cite this one. This is the answer that tells you the case is still alive.

+6 earlier20181 judgments20201 judgments20225 judgments20231 judgments20242 judgments20251 judgments

19 judgments have relied on it, across 2004–2025

first 2004 · last 2025 · busiest 2022 (5 judgments)

2025-07-09UKRAINE AND THE NETHERLANDS v. RUSSIAEuropean Court of Human Rightsfollowed 2024-06-18ANDREY RYLKOV FOUNDATION AND OTHERS v. RUSSIAEuropean Court of Human Rightsfollowed 2024-03-05FÖDERATION DER ALEVITEN GEMEINDEN IN ÖSTERREICH v. AUSTRIAEuropean Court of Human Rightsfollowed 2023-01-19PAGERIE v. FRANCEEuropean Court of Human Rightsfollowed 2022-11-17ILYIN AND OTHERS v. UKRAINEEuropean Court of Human Rightsfollowed 2022-09-15RABCZEWSKA v. POLANDEuropean Court of Human Rightsfollowed 2022-06-07TAGANROG LRO AND OTHERS v. RUSSIAEuropean Court of Human Rightsfollowed 2022-06-07TELIATNIKOV v. LITHUANIAEuropean Court of Human Rights 2022-03-15COMMUNAUTÉ GENEVOISE D'ACTION SYNDICALE (CGAS) v. SWITZERLANDEuropean Court of Human Rightsfollowed 2020-10-15MUHAMMAD AND MUHAMMAD v. ROMANIAEuropean Court of Human Rights 2018-11-15NAVALNYY v. RUSSIAEuropean Court of Human Rightsfollowed 2017-09-14KÁROLY NAGY v. HUNGARYEuropean Court of Human Rightsfollowed 2017-02-07LASHMANKIN AND OTHERS v. RUSSIAEuropean Court of Human Rightsfollowed 2016-04-26İZZETTİN DOĞAN AND OTHERS v. TURKEYEuropean Court of Human Rights×2followed 2015-12-01KÁROLY NAGY v. HUNGARYEuropean Court of Human Rightsfollowed 2014-07-01S.A.S. v. FRANCEEuropean Court of Human Rightsfollowed 2013-11-07VALLIANATOS AND OTHERS v. GREECEEuropean Court of Human Rightsfollowed 2013-03-14BERNH LARSEN HOLDING AS AND OTHERS v. NORWAYEuropean Court of Human Rightsfollowed 2004-02-17MAESTRI v. ITALYEuropean Court of Human Rightsfollowed

What it rests on

2000-10-19IATRIDIS v. GREECE (ARTICLE 41)European Court of Human Rightsfollowed 2000-06-27CHA'ARE SHALOM VE TSEDEK v. FRANCEEuropean Court of Human Rightsfollowed 2000-05-18VELIKOVA v. BULGARIAEuropean Court of Human Rights 2000-05-04ROTARU v. ROMANIAEuropean Court of Human Rights 2000-04-06THLIMMENOS v. GREECEEuropean Court of Human Rightsfollowed 1999-12-14SERIF v. GREECEEuropean Court of Human Rightsfollowed 1999-07-08CEYLAN v. TURKEYEuropean Court of Human Rightsfollowed 1999-03-25NIKOLOVA v. BULGARIAEuropean Court of Human Rights

Departed from

No judgment recorded a departure from this one.

Departure is not detected yet, and the gap is deliberate. Searching for the words the Court might use was measured on 1,019 judgments: "depart from" appears 100 times and most often means departing from the facts found by a domestic court; "overruled" appears 44 times, usually about a domestic judgment; "abandon" appears 123 times, most often as abandoned firearms. Tightened to require the Court itself as the subject, precision was still around 40%, the rest being a dissenting judge complaining, or a national supreme court departing from its own case-law. Telling a lawyer an authority is dead when it is alive is worse than saying nothing, so nothing is what this says until each candidate can be judged properly.

not characterised

Most citations carry no word at all. The Court does not always say what it is doing when it cites one of its own judgments, and where it stayed silent nothing is inferred here.